OPERS and STRS Ohio Survivor Elections: The Pension Choice That’s Hard to Undo

If you spent your career teaching in Beavercreek or Kettering schools, working for Montgomery County, Sinclair, a city water department, or one of the many public employers across the Miami Valley, your OPERS or STRS Ohio pension is probably the biggest financial asset you’ll ever own. And one box on your retirement application decides what happens to it when you die.

That box is your plan of payment. It sets how much you get each month and whether your spouse or another beneficiary keeps receiving a check after you’re gone. For many plans, the choice is locked in once benefits start, with only a few narrow exceptions. Below is what OPERS and STRS Ohio actually allow, drawn from each system’s own publications, and how to think through the decision with your spouse before you sign.

Why This Choice Matters So Much

Many public jobs are not covered by Social Security. The Social Security Administration specifically mentions teachers, firefighters, and police officers in many states. If your OPERS or STRS service wasn’t covered, the pension carries more weight than it would for someone retiring from a private company. If you choose a plan that stops paying when you die, your spouse may lose a large share of household income overnight, at exactly the moment other costs don’t go down.

There is some good news for surviving spouses on the Social Security side. The Social Security Fairness Act, signed into law on January 5, 2025, ended the Windfall Elimination Provision and the Government Pension Offset. Those rules used to reduce or eliminate Social Security benefits for people who receive a pension from work not covered by Social Security. If your spouse has a Social Security record, that may now provide more survivor income than it would have a few years ago. But it rarely replaces a full public pension, so the plan of payment still matters.

OPERS Plan of Payment Options

For members retiring from the OPERS Traditional Pension Plan, OPERS describes these choices:

  • Single Life Plan. An annuity paid only to you, for your lifetime. It’s the largest monthly check, and payments stop at your death.
  • Joint Life Plan. After your death, payment continues to one beneficiary in a specified amount from 10 to 100 percent of your benefit. You pick a whole percentage in that range.
  • Multiple Life Plan. You can name two to four surviving beneficiaries.
  • Partial Lump Sum Option Payment (PLOP). Lets you take a lump sum up front in exchange for a smaller monthly benefit, combined with one of the plans above.

OPERS PLOP limits

OPERS says the lump sum can’t be less than six times or more than 36 times your monthly amount, and it can’t reduce your monthly benefit below 50 percent of what it would have been. The PLOP is issued no sooner than 90 days after your first monthly benefit payment. And once the PLOP has been issued, OPERS says no changes can be made to your plan of payment or to the PLOP amount.

STRS Ohio Plan of Payment Options

STRS Ohio describes three basic plans of payment plus a Partial Lump-Sum Option Plan for Defined Benefit Plan members:

  • Plan I — Single Life Annuity. The highest monthly benefit, paid for your lifetime only.
  • Plan II — Joint and Survivor Annuity. A lifetime benefit to you, with continuing payments to a beneficiary. STRS offers several versions (Options 1 through 4), including a choice of whether the plan includes “reversion,” which matters a great deal later. Option 4 lets you provide lifetime benefits for up to four primary beneficiaries.
  • Plan III — Annuity Certain. Payments for a set period, rather than for a survivor’s lifetime.
  • PLOP. STRS allows a lump sum of six to 36 times your monthly Single Life Annuity benefit, elected in $1,000 increments unless you choose the minimum or maximum.

Limits on beneficiary amounts

Under STRS Option 3, the amount you designate for your beneficiary must be at least $50 per month and can’t exceed 100% of your benefit. STRS also notes that if your primary beneficiary isn’t your spouse, IRS rules may limit the percentage you can leave to that person. Under Option 4, unless a court order says otherwise, each beneficiary’s benefit can’t be less than 10% of yours, and the total to all beneficiaries can’t exceed what you receive.

Spousal Consent Rules

Both systems build in protection for spouses, and the default is the same in spirit.

OPERS

OPERS says that if you’re married at retirement, you must designate a 50 percent Joint Life Plan to your spouse unless you get spousal consent. Your current spouse must give written consent on your retirement application to your choice of plan and beneficiaries. Spousal consent is also required if you’re married and want a PLOP. Without consent, OPERS pays you under the 50 percent Joint Life Plan, without a PLOP, with your spouse as beneficiary.

STRS Ohio

STRS says that without spousal consent, you’ll receive a Joint and Survivor Annuity with one-half to your beneficiary (with reversion) and no PLOP. If you’re married on your benefit effective date, your spouse must consent if you choose a Single Life Annuity, a joint plan that leaves your spouse less than one-half or names someone else, the Annuity Certain plan, or any PLOP. Your spouse signs the consent on the Service Retirement Application before a notary public.

The point of these rules is that a spouse shouldn’t lose survivor income without knowing it. If your spouse is asked to sign, both of you should understand exactly what’s being given up.

What You Can and Can’t Change Later

This is the part people most often get wrong. “I’ll just change it later” usually isn’t an option.

Before benefits are finalized

OPERS says you may change your payment plan any time before your finalized monthly benefit or PLOP is issued, by completing a new retirement application. After that, changes are limited to specific life events.

OPERS life-event changes

  • Your beneficiary dies first: Under the Joint Life Plan, you begin to be paid under the Single Life Plan after you submit the beneficiary’s death certificate.
  • You marry after retiring: For marriages on or after June 6, 2005, you have up to one year from the date of marriage to change your plan to provide for your spouse.
  • Divorce: You may elect the Single Life Plan with your former spouse’s written consent or a court order. A court order can also limit what you’re allowed to change.

STRS Ohio life-event changes

  • Single Life Annuity: If you later marry, you may switch to a Joint and Survivor Annuity for your new spouse within the first year of the marriage. STRS says this is the only circumstance in which a Single Life Annuity can be changed.
  • Joint and Survivor with reversion: If your beneficiary dies before you, you can revert to the Single Life Annuity with a copy of the death certificate. Divorce can also allow a change with your former spouse’s written consent or court documentation.
  • Joint and Survivor without reversion: STRS says neither the plan nor the primary beneficiary can be changed after retirement, even if your beneficiary dies or the marriage ends.
  • Annuity Certain: You can’t select a different plan after retirement.

Notice the difference reversion makes at STRS. If you choose a joint plan without it and your spouse passes away first, you keep the reduced benefit for the rest of your life.

A Worked Example: Single Life vs. Joint

The numbers below are made up to show the trade-off. Your actual reduction for a joint plan depends on your age, your beneficiary’s age, and the percentage you choose, so you’ll need an estimate from OPERS or STRS for real figures.

Say Linda, a retired Greene County teacher, is offered a hypothetical $4,200 a month on a Single Life Annuity. A joint plan leaving her husband Tom 100% might pay her $3,600 a month instead. That’s $600 a month, or $7,200 a year, less while she’s alive.

If Linda lives 25 years in retirement and Tom dies first, the single-life choice would have paid her $180,000 more over that time. But if Linda dies after 8 years and Tom lives another 15, the single-life plan leaves Tom with no pension at all, while the 100% joint plan keeps paying him $3,600 a month, or $648,000 over those 15 years.

That’s the real decision: you’re buying insurance against the risk that the pension holder dies first. Health, age gap, other assets, and your spouse’s own pension or Social Security all feed into it.

What about “pension maximization”?

Some salespeople suggest taking the single-life benefit and buying life insurance to protect the spouse instead. It can work in specific cases, but it depends on qualifying for affordable coverage, keeping the policy in force for life, and the survivor managing a lump sum well. With the systems’ spousal consent rules in place, it’s a decision to make slowly and with a second opinion, not at a kitchen-table pitch.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

  • What are the exact monthly amounts for each plan and percentage? Ask OPERS or STRS for estimates side by side.
  • If I’m an STRS member choosing a joint plan, does it include reversion?
  • How would our household income look if either of us died in year one, year ten, or year twenty?
  • Does a PLOP make sense, given that it permanently lowers the monthly check and limits later changes?
  • Is there a divorce decree or court order that affects my choices?
  • How does my spouse’s Social Security record fit in now that the GPO has been repealed?

We meet with a lot of OPERS and STRS retirees in the Dayton area, and this is one of the few retirement decisions where a mistake can’t easily be fixed afterward. If you’d like a second set of eyes on your estimates before you file, Medicare & Retirement Solutions Group in Beavercreek offers free consultations. Call us or visit medretiregroup.com and we’ll walk through the numbers with you and your spouse.

This article is general educational information, not individualized tax, insurance, or investment advice. Rules and figures change and individual circumstances vary — please confirm details with your plan, or speak with a qualified professional, before acting.

Have questions about your Medicare or retirement plan?

Talk with a licensed local advisor in Beavercreek. No cost and no pressure.

Schedule Your Free Review

Prefer to talk now? Call Today

Scroll to Top